“Though the Witch knew the Deep Magic, there is a magic deeper still which she did not know. Her knowledge goes back only to the dawn of time. But if she could have looked a little further back, into the stillness and the darkness before Time dawned, she would have read there a different incantation.“
— Aslan (C.S. Lewis)
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, Chapter 15
I love this passage from C.S. Lewis’s The Chronicles of Narnia for a number of reasons. Obviously, this is at the part of the story when the Stone Table cracks and Aslan comes back to life, which is a most happy part of the story. That, however, is not the reason I like this passage as I do. The real reason I love it so much is because of the deep truth that it reveals about the Christian faith, and, most especially, the Christian Scriptures.
On the most facile interpretation, Lewis seems to be alluding to the distinction that Paul the Apostle makes between the Old and New Law in his epistle to the Romans. The Old Law was indeed a condemnation unto death, while the New Law is a covenant which brings life in Christ. But there’s another layer to this idea, and it’s one captured by Paul when he says (in reference to the Law) that “the letter kills, but the Spirit gives life” (2 Cor 3:6). Jesus seems to suggest a similar meaning when He condemns the Pharisees: “You search the scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that testify on my behalf. Yet you refuse to come to me to have life” (John 5:39-40).
When it comes to the Scripture, there have been a variety of methods proposed for interpreting it properly. By far, the most widespread and popular method today (at least in academic circles) is something called the “historical-critical method.” Basically, this method relies on modern/postmodern textual-critical theory to try and understand the text in its historical context. This involves complicated linguistic work that finds variants in spellings, particular grammatical structures, and other textual features to isolate and identify potential influences on the text.
For example, there's something called "Pentateuchal Source Theory" which suggests, on the basis of the Hebrew manuscripts we have, that the first five books of the Scriptures (the Torah) were actually assembled piecemeal from four different pre-second-Temple Jewish sources. Why is this important? Well, these textual critics argue that by dissecting the Scriptures in these ways, they can better understand the intentions of the Scriptural authors than they could without the insights gained by these critical examinations—such as, say, many laypeople and even religious leaders.
To be clear, I’m not suggesting that there’s no value to the historical-critical method. Many of the earliest Christian saints, such as Jerome Hieronymus, were very exacting in their scriptural studies (and rightfully so)! Where it becomes problematic, however, is in the naturalistic assumptions that many of these critics have. Many of them see the text purely as a cultural artifact, and not as a sacred document. Even when otherwise orthodox Christians use these methods, there’s a degree to which they’re using secularized—and often atheistic—tools to do an inherently religious task.
In contrast to this method, the Church has her own tried-and-true tradition of interpretation. Within the Church’s rich history, Catholic thinkers have often divided the meaning of the Scriptures into distinct categories or “levels” (they’re called “senses” in the Catechism, CCC 115-119). These are the “literal” (the most basic form of interpretation, and the “spiritual”—which is subdivided into the “allegorical,” “moral,” and “anagogical.” The basic idea is that, as you proceed from level to level, you find a deeper and richer understanding of the text. This does not mean the initial levels are “shallow” while the advanced levels are “deep”—each advanced level is rooted in the insights gleaned from preceding levels. But the layered-ness of the Scriptures cannot be uncovered by a literal reading of the text only; one must go deeper to plumb the deeper riches.
And here I return to Lewis’s passage about “deep” magic and “deeper” magic. As helpful as the historical-critical method may be, its scope is limited only to the most superficial insights about the Scriptures. Many biblical scholars go their whole lives obsessing over the nuances of the text—the “letter of the law,” if you will—without ever coming to appreciate the substance and Spirit of the Word. The latter is something that can only be achieved with the light of faith and the guidance of the Church. Ultimately, our reading of Scripture should be less focused on knowing man and his history—rather, we should strive there to learn of God and His eternity. For that end, we will find no greater guides than the great Doctors and teachers of the Church.