In Defense of Erotic Love
In the seminal text on eros, Plato’s Symposium, Socrates recounts how a woman, Diotima, taught him erotics.5 All humans are desirous of beauty. We wish to possess beautiful things, to make them ours. We associate this desire most clearly with the feeling of being in love and particularly with sex. The lover longs to satisfy themselves in the beloved, to experience ecstasy, wholeness, and rest. When the lover is satisfied in the beloved, the lover is happy. All humans are desirous of happiness. Here, Diotima helps Socrates understand that eros, the erotic love common to all men and women, is the desire of beautiful things and of being happy.6
The lesson of Diotima is that our erotic desire for a beloved can lead us to the divine. To be skilled in erotics is to understand that our “common eros” can and should lead us upward to a “heavenly eros.” Eros is an ascending love calling us up a “ladder of love,” as we move from one rung to another until we can satiate in the divine beauty-itself.8 For Socrates, the philosopher is a lover, a lover of beautiful things, and the philosophic life is the most erotic life, because it can ascend to what our erotic love yearns for most: infinite beauty.9
“The Prophets,” Pope Benedict XVI teaches, “described God’s passion for his people using boldly erotic images.”10 In Ezekiel, God looks upon Israel as a young woman “arrived in maidenhood.” He tells her, “your breasts were formed, and your hair had grown; yet you were naked and bare.” And, “When I passed by you again and looked upon you, behold, you were at the age for love.” God takes her as His own, enters into covenant with her, and bathes and clothes her as His bride (Eze 16:6-14). God and Israel at Mount Sinai is read as a marriage (Ex 19:1-9). He is the husband and she the bride (Jer 31:32; Is 54:5-6). When Israel commits idolatry, God condemns her for adultery against her true Husband. She plays the “harlot” offering her beauty to her “lustful neighbors” (Eze 16:15-58). God portrays Himself as the angry, jealous Husband of the unfaithful wife (Eze 16:42).
God uses the common eros of man to explain how our heavenly eros is only to be sated in Him—to do otherwise is spiritual adultery.
Second, others see eros and agape as largely indistinguishable. Neither Plato nor St. Paul invented the terms eros or agape. They existed prior to their specific philosophical or spiritual definitions and represent a broader range of concepts. Moreover, a Church Father in the East may speak only of eros or speak of agape as a type of eros, while a Western Father may engage eros and agape only through their various translations into Latin. Consequently, a strict historical claim on the precise meaning of eros or agape runs counter to the legitimate plurality of philosophical traditions that have been used to express these words for love.17 While this second approach to the issue of eros and agape has merit, the various uses of these terms do not preclude the predominant meanings of eros and agape from being parsed and presented as two harmonious movements of love. Following the tutelage of Pope Benedict XVI, the third approach draws from the Catholic tradition to offer eros and agape as the ascent and descent of the soul.18
Few have charted the ascent of soul like St. Gregory of Nyssa or Dante Alighieri. St. Gregory, one of the Cappadocian Fathers, reads the lover in the Song of Songs as climbing the ladder of virtue toward her Beloved.19 Moses ascends Mount Sinai and slips into the “bright darkness” of God, as Elijah is drawn upward into heaven by Beauty-itself.20 The soul soars on wings to celestial delights or climbs up the great chain linking the soul to God.21 Eros, St. Gregory observes, is like a flame tending ever upward and never downward.22 He even portrays Christ as an archer, like the god Eros or Cupid, shooting the lover with the arrow of eros to draw her toward Himself.23
Agape is a descent. If eros is the natural love that leads us to God, then agape is the supernatural love that is only infused in us after we partake in the Divine Life. Agape is caritas, charity, the greatest of the theological virtues. Eros is a need-love, a virtuous self-love, while agape is a gift-love, a selfless and self-sacrificial love. In eros a person knows that he or she is loved by God, and in agape the person attempts to love God and others as God has loved them. It is the harmony between Christ promising eternal satisfaction to all who hunger and thirst with Christ also commanding persons pick up their cross and crucify themselves.
As our Lord teaches, the greatest commandment is to love God, and the second is “you shall love your neighbor as yourself” (Matt 22:37-39). Our self-love is the standard for our love of neighbor.27 To be truly skilled in erotics is to understand that the lover must first find satisfaction in the Beloved before she knows how to love her neighbor. She must cultivate a virtuous self-love of giving herself to God in the nuptial mysteries of holy eros in order to love her neighbor as she has been loved and as she loves herself. As St. Augustine proclaims, “For Thou hast made us for Thyself and our hearts are restless till they rest in Thee.”28 It is to this rest that we invite our neighbors.
References
[1] Josef Pieper, Faith, Hope, Love (Ignatius Press, San Francisco, 1997), 174
[2] C.S. Lewis, The Four Loves (Harcourt Books, Inc., Orlando, 1988), 1-2; 91-115.
[3] Pieper, 222, 234.
[4] Pope Benedict XVI, Deus Caritas Est, 2006, n. 5.
[5] Plato, trans. Seth Benardete, Symposium (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 2001), 201D.
[6] Symposium, 205D; also, 202C; 204E; one may also say “good,” as good and beauty are both transcendentals for Plato.
[7] Symposium, 206A; 208A-B; 210A-211E.
[8] See Allan Bloom’s essay, “The Ladder of Love,” Symposium, 55, ff.
[9] Symposium, 57, 147; 150.
[10] Deus Caritas Est, n. 9.
[11] Symposium, 107.
[12] Deus Caritas Est, n. 10.
[13] Deus Caritas Est, n. 10.
[14] God cannot have a “need-love,” as he is perfect; thus, God’s use of erotic imagery for his love is understood as an analogy. Though, some Neoplatonic Church Fathers will state, “God is Eros,” but this is only insofar as he loves and knows Himself.
[15] See Anders Nygren, Agape and Eros (Westminster Press, Philadelphia, 1953); Thomas M. Osborne, Jr., Love of Self and Love of God in Thirteen-Century Ethics (University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, 2005), 13.
[16] Deus Caritas Est, n. 2-18.
[17] Pieper, 153, 155; Nygren, 440; Osborne, 14-16.
[18] Deus Caritas Est, n. 7.
[19] Agape and Eros, 441-42.
[20] Agape and Eros, 432, 443.
[21] Id.,
[22] Id., 446.
[23] Id., 445.
[24] Dante Alighieri, Paradise, Canto XXXI.100.
[25] Deus Caritas Est, n. 7.
[26] See footnote 14.
[27] Osborne, 13-15.
[28] St. Augustine, trans. F.J. Sheed, Confessions (Hackett Publishing Company, Inc., Indianapolis, 2006), 3 (I.I.1).
This article has been reprinted with permission from the Eastern Oklahoma Catholic, a publication of the Diocese of Tulsa and Eastern Oklahoma.
Dcn. Harrison Garlick
Dcn. Harrison Garlick serves as the Chancellor for the Diocese of Tulsa and is a Great Books tutor for the Alcuin Institute for Catholic Culture.